Little Miss Treason

From The Nation, 2/17/04:
http://www.thenation.com/outrage/index.mhtml?pid=1262

Little Miss Treason

By Matt Bivens


We'll get to the loathsome likes of Little Miss Treason shortly, but
first let's look at the man she has libeled:

Max Cleland.

Cleland lost both legs and an arm in Vietnam, wounds that could have
destroyed a lesser man.

Instead, he not only kept his life together, he made it all the way to
the United States Senate.

In the fall of 2002, control of Congress hinged on his seat, and the
GOP leadership poured its black heart into his defeat.

President George Bush visited Georgia five times to campaign against
him, and a Republican ad campaign likened Cleland to -- of course --
Osama bin Laden.

Old-school Republicans like John McCain and Chuck Hagel, who both
served in Vietnam, were appalled.

But the new-school Bushies, morals all a-AWOL, were pleased to do
whatever it took to pick up Cleland's seat.

Fast-forward 18 months.

Today, George W. Bush is scrambling to put a good face on how he spent
the Vietnam war.

(To recap: States-side, in a cush gig brokered by his daddy just 12
days before he'd have again been eligible for the draft, he learned at
taxpayer expense to fly a fighter jet, then announced he wanted to
campaign for an Alabama pal of Richard Nixon's, stopped showing up,
then declined to provide that embarrassing urine sample and so lost
his flight status, then "arranged it with the military" to leave early
to go get an M.B.A. Mission accomplished!)

Those asking harsh questions about the President's frivolous
relationship with his military duties include Cleland.

This is driving the Bush Republicans crazy.

After all, it's embarrassing to have a true-blue war hero point out
that your guy is a true-blue phony.

So the new strategy is the old strategy:

Smear Cleland.

How dare he question our President!

He must be a traitor!

And he's certainly no hero, says Coulter.

After a spit-fleckled rant against those who have permitted themselves
to question the Great Leader's National Guard service, she says:


"If we're going to start delving into exactly who did what back then,
maybe Max Cleland should stop allowing Democrats to portray him as a
war hero who lost his limbs taking enemy fire on the battlefields of
Vietnam.

"Cleland lost three limbs in an accident during a routine non-combat
mission where he was about to drink beer with friends. He saw a
grenade on the ground and picked it up. He could have done that at
Fort Dix. ... Luckily for Cleland's political career and current
pomposity about Bush, he happened to do it while in Vietnam. ...

"Cleland ... didn't 'give his limbs for his country,' or leave them
'on the battlefield.' There was no bravery involved in dropping a
grenade on himself with no enemy troops in sight."


Coulter's account has already been applauded by someone named Mark
Steyn who writes for The Washington Times.

"As Ann Coulter pointed out in a merciless but entirely accurate
column, it wasn't on the 'battlefield.' It wasn't in combat," Steyn
writes.

"[Cleland] was working on a radio relay station. He saw a grenade
dropped by one of his colleagues and bent down to pick it up. It's
impossible for most of us to imagine what that must be like -- to be
flown home, with your body shattered, not because of some firefight,
but because of a stupid mistake."

(The clear implication is that Cleland was stupid enough to blow
himself up and has to live with that.)

Steyn goes on to say Cleland is happy "to be passed off" as a hero,
because that makes him "a more valuable mascot."

* * *

It's hard to know how to continue, because all I want to do is direct
an awful string of insults and profanity at Coulter and Steyn.

Instead, I'll just lay out Max Cleland's record.

First of all, Cleland was wounded during the siege of Khe Sanh.

Khe Sanh, for Christ's sake!

I know the smug Bush Republicans are utterly ahistorical, but surely
they've heard of Khe Sanh?

Let's help them out.

Here is a fine timeline by PBS of the Vietnam war for 1968.

I'll quote a three-month stretch of it here, February, March and
April:

February 23, 1968 -- Over 1,300 artillery rounds hit the Marine base
at Khe Sanh and its outposts, more than on any previous day of
attacks. To withstand the constant assaults, bunkers at Khe Sanh are
rebuilt to withstand 82mm mortar rounds.

March 6, 1968 -- While Marines wait for a massive assault, NVA forces
retreat into the jungle around Khe Sanh. For the next three weeks,
things are relatively quiet around the base.

March 11, 1968 -- Massive search and destroy sweeps are launched
against Vietcong remnants around Saigon and other parts of South
Vietnam.

March 16, 1968 -- In the hamlet of My Lai, US Charlie Company kills
about two hundred civilians. Although only one member of the division
is tried and found guilty of war crimes, the repercussions of the
atrocity is felt throughout the Army. However rare, such acts undid
the benefit of countless hours of civic action by Army units and
individual soldiers and raised unsettling questions about the conduct
of the war.

March 22, 1968 -- Without warning, a massive North Vietnamese barrage
slams into Khe Sanh. More than 1,000 rounds hit the base, at a rate of
a hundred every hour. At the same time, electronic sensors around Khe
Sanh indicate NVA troop movements. American forces reply with heavy
bombing.

April 8, 1968 -- US forces in Operation Pegasus finally retake Route
9, ending the siege of Khe Sanh. A 77-day battle, Khe Sanh had been
the biggest single battle of the Vietnam War to that point. The
official assessment of the North Vietnamese Army dead is just over
1,600 killed, with two divisions all but annihilated. But thousands
more were probably killed by American bombing.

April 8, 1968, was also the day that Captain Max Cleland lost both
legs and an arm. He had less than a week earlier already earned
commendations for heroism during some of the bloodiest combat of the
whole Khe Sanh siege -- combat missions for which he had volunteered,
so as to relieve stranded Marines and Army infantry. The order in
which the President awarded him the Silver Star reads:


"Captain Cleland distinguished himself by exceptionally valorous
action on 4 April 1968, while serving as communications officer of the
2nd Battalion, 12th Calvary during an enemy attack near Khe Sanh,
Republic of Vietnam.

"When the battalion command post came under a heavy enemy rocket and
mortar attack, Capt. Cleland, disregarding his own safety, exposed
himself to the rocket barrage as he left his covered position to
administer first aid to his wounded comrades. He then assisted in
moving the injured personnel to covered positions. Continuing to
expose himself, Capt. Cleland organized his men into a work party to
repair the battalion communications equipment, which had been damaged
by enemy fire. His gallant action is in keeping with the highest
traditions of the military service, and reflects great credit upon
himself, his unit, and the United States Army."


Here, in a speech he was invited to give about character, is how
Cleland himself tells what happened next:

"I remember standing on the edge of the bomb crater that had been my
home for five days and five nights, stretching my six-foot, two-inch
frame, and becoming caught up in excitement. The battle for Khe Sanh
was over, and I had come out of it unhurt and alive! Five terrible
days and nights were behind us. In spite of dire predictions, we had
held Khe Sanh. I had scored a personal victory over myself and my
fears. ... My tour of duty in Vietnam was almost over. In another
month I'd be going home. I smiled, thinking of the good times waiting
stateside.

"On April 8, 1968, I volunteered for one last mission. The helicopter
moved in low. The troops jumped out with M16 rifles in hand as we
crouched low to the ground to avoid the helicopter blades. Then I saw
the grenade. It was where the chopper had lifted off. It must be mine,
I thought. Grenades had fallen off my web gear before. Shifting the
M16 to my left hand and holding it behind me, I bent down to pick up
the grenade.

"A blinding explosion threw me backwards."


Ann Coulter, the facts be damned, calls this "a routine non-combat
mission where he was about to drink beer with friends," and says
"there was no bravery involved."

Mark Steyn says Cleland is happy "to be passed off" as a hero.

And both, incredibly, characterize Cleland's wounds as good fortune.

But just because these two hacks think losing limbs to advance their
Republican political careers would be a lucky trade -- hell, they've
already given away their souls, what's an arm or a leg? -- doesn't
mean the rest of us share their warped priorities.

I mean, Khe Sanh!
-=-
This message was posted via two or more anonymous remailing services.